

For anyone familiar with the fracas over the 'Hobbit' fossils (Homo Floresiensis, a 3' tall, 18,000 year-old hominin skeleton discovered in a cave on Indonesia's Flores Island four years ago) the latest study by a team from the Smithsonian offers the potential for more fun! The team that discovered the 'Hobbit' firmly believed it was a new species of human. This claim was roundly refuted by many researchers who thought it much more likely that the unusual remains were due to either a growth deficiency or a skeletal pathology. Much unedifying and rancorous academic noise and posturing followed. The latest study starts with a different take on what defines us as human. Scientists tend to bang on about our big brains, use of language, skills with tools and even our complex social relationships. However, one facet of our anatomy which indisputably differentiates us from other apes and our early ancestors is our wrists! Wrist bones so I now know turn out to be complex bits of kit, making them quite useful in understanding the evolutionary relationships between living species and our fossil ancestors. Once again, it's a case of understanding that which unites us (modern humans and Neanderthals) and that which makes us different (early hominins, the great apes and Homo Floresiensis)! The 'Hobbit's' wrist is identical to those of African apes and early hominins and totally different to that of modern humans. The 'Hobbit' appears to be a new species of human as originally proposed, rather than a diseased individual as had been asserted. Over to the chorus of disbelievers!
Note: Analysing H. Floresiensis wrist structure depended on using advanced 3-D technology techniques developed only in the past few years at the Partnership for research in Spatial Modeling at Arizona State University (PRISM). The researchers who later analysed H. Floresiensis wrist structure happened to work there as graduate assistants where they learned to apply the technology. http://uwnews.washington.edu/ni/article.asp?articleID=37120 Image: 1. Virtual comparison of wrist bones from a Chimpanzee, Hobbit and modern human, Human Origins Program, Smithsonian Institute/Matt Tocheri 2. Artists impression of H. Floresiensis,www.elbakin.net 3. Hobbit and modern human skulls, www.nationalgeographic.com